Home / Faith Debates / Religious Freedom
What Limits to Religious Freedom?
Wednesday 18 April 2012, held at Sixty One Whitehall
Religion and freedom has become a highly controversial area. Some people feel religious freedom is under threat, with recent rulings banning prayer, crucifixes and so on. Other people feel that it is religion which is itself inhibiting freedom of expression, as with the Rushdie affair or the Danish cartoons. Who is right, and how should the issues be resolved? Listen here to podcasts and watch the video of the presentations, responses and discussion at this debate. These are listed at the foot of the page, together with texts of the presentations. The debate was chaired by Charles Clarke and Linda Woodhead.
- Podcast 1: Professor Linda Woodhead [Lancaster University, Director of the Religion and Society Programme] introduced the debate and set it in context. Preceded by a welcome by Charles Clarke. 8.38
- Podcast 2: Professor Peter Jones [Newcastle University], who led the research network on “Religion, Discrimination and Accommodation” proposed resolving conflicts about freedom of expression on the basis of respect. 11.10
- Podcast 3: Professor Maleiha Malik [King’s College, London] argued that the public does need legal protection against some actions based on religious conscience. 12.09
- Podcast 4: Lisa Appignanesi [Author, and President of English PEN], responding, argued from the position of championing freedom of expression to criticise religion. 10.16
- Podcast 5: Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali [President of the Oxford Centre for Training, Research, Advocacy and Development], responding, argued that law is being used inappropriately to limit religious freedom of conscience. 8.56
- Podcast 6: Baroness Julia Neuberger [Senior Rabbi at West London Synagogue], responding, believed society should have a consensus on values and respect, supported by law. 10.12
- Podcast 7: Questions and comments from the audience, and responses by the panel. 42.54
Speakers
- Identity
- Faith in Schools
- Radicalisation
- Religion and Welfare
- Religious Freedom
- Trends
- Public Life
- Media Coverage
To subscribe top our mail list please e-mail:
p.ainsworth@lancaster.ac.uk
array(8) { [0]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "1" ["name"]=> string(4) "Home" ["slug"]=> string(4) "home" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(0) { } } [1]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(5) "About" ["slug"]=> string(5) "about" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(5) { [0]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "1" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(8) "Our Aims" ["slug"]=> string(8) "our_aims" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(5) "About" ["slug"]=> string(5) "about" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [1]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(8) "The Team" ["slug"]=> string(8) "the_team" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(5) "About" ["slug"]=> string(5) "about" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(3) { [0]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "3" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(14) "Peta Ainsworth" ["slug"]=> string(14) "peta_ainsworth" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" } [1]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "4" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(24) "Professor Linda Woodhead" ["slug"]=> string(24) "professor_linda_woodhead" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } [2]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "5" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(16) "Dr Rebecca Catto" ["slug"]=> string(16) "dr_rebecca_catto" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" } } } [2]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "3" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(20) "Programme Management" ["slug"]=> string(20) "programme_management" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(5) "About" ["slug"]=> string(5) "about" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(3) { [0]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(14) "Specifications" ["slug"]=> string(14) "specifications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" } [1]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "7" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(13) "Commissioning" ["slug"]=> string(13) "commissioning" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } [2]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "8" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(18) "Steering Committee" ["slug"]=> string(18) "steering_committee" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" } } } [3]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "4" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(14) "Annual Reports" ["slug"]=> string(14) "annual_reports" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "4" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(5) "About" ["slug"]=> string(5) "about" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [4]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "5" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(16) "Project Guidance" ["slug"]=> string(16) "project_guidance" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "2" ["name"]=> string(5) "About" ["slug"]=> string(5) "about" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } } } [2]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(19) "Research & Findings" ["slug"]=> string(17) "research_findings" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(2) { [0]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(17) "Featured Findings" ["slug"]=> string(17) "featured_findings" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(19) "Research & Findings" ["slug"]=> string(17) "research_findings" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [1]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(1) "7" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(8) "Projects" ["slug"]=> string(8) "projects" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "3" ["name"]=> string(19) "Research & Findings" ["slug"]=> string(17) "research_findings" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(5) { [0]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(1) "9" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "7" ["name"]=> string(8) "Overview" ["slug"]=> string(8) "overview" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" } [1]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "7" ["name"]=> string(23) "Large research projects" ["slug"]=> string(23) "large_research_projects" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" } [2]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(2) "11" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "7" ["name"]=> string(24) "Small research projects " ["slug"]=> string(23) "small_research_projects" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" } [3]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(2) "12" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "7" ["name"]=> string(22) "Networks and workshops" ["slug"]=> string(22) "networks_and_workshops" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "4" } [4]=> array(8) { ["id"]=> string(2) "16" ["menu_submenu_id"]=> string(1) "7" ["name"]=> string(31) "Collaborative PhD studentships " ["slug"]=> string(30) "collaborative_phd_studentships" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(0) "" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(0) "" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" } } } } } [3]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "4" ["name"]=> string(4) "News" ["slug"]=> string(4) "news" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "4" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(0) { } } [4]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(6) "Events" ["slug"]=> string(6) "events" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(3) { [0]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(14) "Featured Event" ["slug"]=> string(14) "featured_event" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(6) "Events" ["slug"]=> string(6) "events" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [1]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "11" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(16) "Programme Events" ["slug"]=> string(16) "programme_events" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(6) "Events" ["slug"]=> string(6) "events" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [2]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "12" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(20) "Non-Programme Events" ["slug"]=> string(20) "non_programme_events" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "5" ["name"]=> string(6) "Events" ["slug"]=> string(6) "events" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } } } [5]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(8) { [0]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "13" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(5) "Books" ["slug"]=> string(5) "books" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [1]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "14" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(16) "Journal Articles" ["slug"]=> string(16) "journal_articles" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [2]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "15" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(8) "Chapters" ["slug"]=> string(8) "chapters" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [3]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "16" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(5) "Print" ["slug"]=> string(5) "print" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "4" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [4]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "17" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(18) "Radio & Television" ["slug"]=> string(16) "radio_television" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [5]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "18" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(8) "Podcasts" ["slug"]=> string(8) "podcasts" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [6]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "19" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(16) "Papers & Reports" ["slug"]=> string(14) "papers_reports" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "7" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [7]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "20" ["menu_id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(14) "External Links" ["slug"]=> string(14) "external_links" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "6" ["name"]=> string(12) "Publications" ["slug"]=> string(12) "publications" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } } } [6]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(1) "7" ["name"]=> string(7) "Contact" ["slug"]=> string(7) "contact" ["meta_title"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_description"]=> string(1) "-" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(1) "-" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "7" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(0) { } } [7]=> array(2) { ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenu"]=> array(8) { [0]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "30" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(8) "Identity" ["slug"]=> string(8) "identity" ["meta_title"]=> string(23) "Faith Debate - Identity" ["meta_description"]=> string(23) "Faith Debate - Identity" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(23) "Faith Debate - Identity" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "1" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [1]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "31" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(16) "Faith in Schools" ["slug"]=> string(16) "faith_in_schools" ["meta_title"]=> string(31) "Faith Debate - Faith in Schools" ["meta_description"]=> string(31) "Faith Debate - Faith in Schools" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(31) "Faith Debate - Faith in Schools" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "2" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [2]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "32" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(14) "Radicalisation" ["slug"]=> string(14) "radicalisation" ["meta_title"]=> string(29) "Faith Debate - Radicalisation" ["meta_description"]=> string(29) "Faith Debate - Radicalisation" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(29) "Faith Debate - Radicalisation" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "3" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [3]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "33" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(20) "Religion and Welfare" ["slug"]=> string(20) "religion_and_welfare" ["meta_title"]=> string(35) "Faith Debate - Religion and Welfare" ["meta_description"]=> string(35) "Faith Debate - Religion and Welfare" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(35) "Faith Debate - Religion and Welfare" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "4" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [4]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "34" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(17) "Religious Freedom" ["slug"]=> string(17) "religious_freedom" ["meta_title"]=> string(32) "Faith Debate - Religious Freedom" ["meta_description"]=> string(32) "Faith Debate - Religious Freedom" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(32) "Faith Debate - Religious Freedom" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "5" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [5]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "35" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(6) "Trends" ["slug"]=> string(6) "trends" ["meta_title"]=> string(21) "Faith Debate - Trends" ["meta_description"]=> string(21) "Faith Debate - Trends" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(21) "Faith Debate - Trends" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "6" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [6]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "37" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(11) "Public Life" ["slug"]=> string(11) "public_life" ["meta_title"]=> string(26) "Faith Debate - Public Life" ["meta_description"]=> string(26) "Faith Debate - Public Life" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(26) "Faith Debate - Public Life" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "7" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } [7]=> array(10) { ["id"]=> string(2) "36" ["menu_id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(14) "Media Coverage" ["slug"]=> string(14) "media_coverage" ["meta_title"]=> string(14) "Media Coverage" ["meta_description"]=> string(14) "Media Coverage" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(14) "Media Coverage" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" ["Menu"]=> array(7) { ["id"]=> string(2) "10" ["name"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["slug"]=> string(13) "faith_debates" ["meta_title"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_description"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["meta_keywords"]=> string(13) "Faith Debates" ["order_number"]=> string(1) "8" } ["MenuSubmenuItem"]=> array(0) { } } } } }